Hence, we will try and understand the difference between joint compound vs. spackling and also look at other important points. Due to certain fast-dry formulations, the tubs always seems to dry out over time though no matter how careful you are. Spackle is a drywall joint compound normally used in construction. Note: Most of the preferred “old style” heavy spackle is also a pain to use in comparison to joint compound because it drys really hard and is a total pain to sand down. Getting two smaller tubs vs one large may be better in the long run if you rarely use it. We're Here to Help. Drywall joint compound vs. Spackle Joint compound is the better choice for taping and finishing drywall seams whereas spackle is the better choice for filling in small to large sized holes in your walls. That stuff just smells so weird I can't get over the stank. In my general area, “topping” does not seem to be a commonly used product. Find communities you're interested in, and become part of an online community! If you are new here, please review posting/commenting guidelines. You can use either spackle or joint compound. Alright I won't get a tub then I promise. Joint compound tends to crack if used in too thin of an amount. Every DIY video I find with fixing our problem, someone is using joint compound/drywall mud for the application of the tape. Never use joint compound without priming it afterward. Is there something I should be looking out for? Moreover, some people still think they are alike, whereas if you look deeply into them, you’ll easily get the contradictions. From eyeglasses, to office chairs, cherished childhood stuffed animals, and trinkets and toys. The plaster itself consists of a mixture of lime or gypsum, an aggregate such as sand, and water. Spackle is a plaster made out of gypsum and glue; whereas, joint compound is composed of water, limestone, hydrated obsidian, foam rubber and clay materials. Posted by 2 years ago. Spackle Vs. Joint Compound? Being two parts it can easily store unaffected by the environment for the most part. So I'm patching holes in our drywall at the moment and there's a hole that's maybe 1/2" around. So, if you want to protect your spackle or mud from going bad even before applying them, we recommend … Now the question might arouse that which one is best for wall repairing project and heavy renovation? Plaster sets quickly and is generally more difficult to work than joint compound or patching compound. I'm pretty sure I screwed up and used spackle when I should have used joint compound. There is a host of different drywall compounds available, both fast drying and the stuff that does take quite a spell to dry. The plaster is troweled onto the wall surface wet, and when it dries, it forms a very hard, durable surface. Press J to jump to the feed. My question is, is it still ok to use the lightweight spackling for this or do I need to get joint compound? She brought back lightweight spackling as that is what someone from our local ACE said to use for our problem. Drydex comes in tubes as well as the usual tubs. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the HomeImprovement community. Setting-type joint compound, lightweight joint compound, all-purpose compound and others all have their unique uses. Doors, walls, furniture and floors, popcorn ceilings *and* ceiling fans. I wouldn't be too concerned with strength. Jump ToWhat is Spackle?Spackle UsesWhat is Joint Compound?Joint Compound UsesSpackle vs. Joint Compound – Conclusion Most houses built within the ... Read moreSpackle vs. Joint Compound: What are the Differences? In short, use caulk for corners and edges, use wood filler for flat surfaces, and use spackle for drywall. Now, that doesn’t mean you can’t fill holes with a quality joint compound, but joint compound typically dries much slower than spackle. It’s a good question to ask. I only ever buy drywall compound in dry powder form. We used Non-Shrink Spackling Compound from Sherwin Williams to spackle nail holes on our pole barn after applying Sherwin Williams tinted prime. Let the retailers worry about shelf life and spoilage. Take a Minute to finally learn the difference between spackle and joint compound! 2. A fresher tub of either will always be better than an old dried out tub of either. While plaster-and-lath construction was common in older homes, walls in modern … Joint Compound vs. Spackle. Joint compound is the better choice for taping and finishing drywall seams whereas Spackle is the better choice for filling in small to large sized holes in your walls. What about the main point - the difference between spackle v joint compound? You are really only concerned with strength when taping long drywall seams so you don't need it when patching small holes. Most every product is at least as strong as the wall it's going on. For things that don't need to be white, bondo (all purpose) is great for keeping around the house for years. A tiny bit will last forever. I know drywall joint compound and spackling paste are two different things. https://www.askdavethepainter.com Here I will discuss various putties; spackle; and joint compound. Tape joints with paper tape and all-purpose premixed joint compound. Always comes out either too watery or too thick. Even dry mixes of both spackle and joint compound will absorb moisture over months of sitting and become perform worse when used. Joint compound is the better selection to tape, sand, and finish drywall seams. I was going to use Joint Compound for it. Don't buy the the one gallon container unless you are a professional painter. It will go bad long before you can use all of it. You can get a bag of 20 minute drywall compound. Yes. Each product has a different use. Use spackle instead of joint compound, on small holes. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Spackle is designed more for major patching, it can be put on thickly and it will still set, with joint compound if you put a large amount on it is likely to crack and flake, not designed for that. I keep a bag in my work truck sealed in a trash bag with a twist tie. Joint compound vs. spackling. Traditional spackle is a putty-like hole filler akin to joint compound, but modern products are made with … Was hoping that if I sand down the spackle that is on there I could fix my mistake and put joint compound on top of it. Joint compound is really easy to sand thus giving it one more feather in its cap. Joint compound to me is something that can also do a skim coat, 'spackle' as we know it up here can't do that (well, shouldn't do that, I know people who do but it doesn't work very well). It’s easy to apply and sand, it’s odorless, and easy to clean up. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. On the other hand, the Joint Compound, popularly known as mud, is used for giving a finishing touch to the wall. Another difference between the two is in their compositions. And on the contrary, spackle is for filling in small to large-sized holes in your walls. I'd especially use it for any repair requiring tape. Some spackling doesn't shrink as much as joint compound does, but plaster of Paris doesn't seem to shrink at all, and for big repairs I use it because it cures very fast. Here's the difference between joint compound vs. spackle. Archived. Hole in drywall - Joint Compound or Spackle. It also has very low shrinkage and enough tensile strength to get the job done. Joint compound vs spackle: Final Feedback If you want to tackle the wall installation or repair like a pro, you need to know the differences. When installing drywall, joint compound, or mud, is an essential component of this process for filling seams and screw holes.But what type is best: wet, pre-mixed joint compound or dry joint compound? You go get what you need when you need it. If you get something and plan on keeping it around keep in mind that it will probably be hard by the time you need it. like this... Also comes in a small box for a couple of bucks. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I always use joint compound if I can help it, but that stuff dries rock hard and must be sanded flat and painted. Spackling compound, often identified simply as spackle, is available at any hardware store, and it's inexpensive, costing about $5 for a pint container. D) Cut out entire area which has been defiled by the spackle. Press J to jump to the feed. Drys in ~20 mins and you dont have to refill dimples. There are some instances, where you will find the bottom layer of the compound usable but it will lose a bit of its strength. It's better to have a small box of hot mud that you can mix when you need it. Buy small, no point having a huge tub of it if it's useless when you need it. Sure, they might all get the job done for awhile, but each of these patches has a special purpose and a best place to use them. Can you put joint compound on top of spackling paste? I'm confused because I have had the same tub of the pink drydex for about a year now and still use it. Spackling seems to be be more Ph neutral so that you can repair around paint/stain/varnish without loosening the surrounding finishes. Should you use caulk or wood filler or spackle? While it can be used in place of spackling, in a pinch, spackling is always your best choice for small holes. It is now also available in a ready-made paste.Joint compound is a substance that is actually often referred to as 'drywall mud' and is of a similar consistency to plaster. Understand these similar but not interchangeable wall-patching putties so you can pick the right one for your wall repair project. I use joint compound for everything. Most people just spackle a hole flush and call it a day. It's a fraction of the price, and it doesn't go bad. It was used for some old television cable. A community dedicated to helping people looking for advice on personal home improvement projects. Plaster wall surfaces are constructed from layers of hard plaster that are built up over a wood or metal framework called lath. Spackle vs Mud. If I can't get the plaster exactly right, I leave the patch a bit concave so I can fill it later with drywall compound. You can use either spackle or joint compound. Close. Topping vs joint compound Hey guys, I’m in the REO/Foreclosure business located in NJ right outside of Philly. Remember shelf life. Get some zinsser ready patch spackling compound. Reddit is a network of communities based on people's interests. Someone here is going to try to help you fix it when it's busted. If it's just for filling holes, get some 1 Time. If you get a large tub of either, you'll end up having most of it go bad and throwing it out. A 1 quart metal can can last for years and is enough to repaint several rooms. I also have a bunch of small holes in another room I'm going to paint that are from nails used to hang pictures. By the time you go to use it again, it's crusty or moldy. It requires the taking down of the drywall joint tape and putting new drywall joint tape up. spackle is almost more like clay, it'll dry and shrink. Dura bond is my go to - the bags you mix store forever if stored in a leftover container. It was originally produced in powder form, which needed to be mixed with water in order to be used. It's not usually strength which makes masonry products separate. If you leave a container of joint compound in the open air, you will see the product is not as it should be. Note: Most of the preferred “old style” heavy spackle is also a pain to use in comparison to joint compound because it drys really hard and is a total pain to sand down. Joint Compound vs Spackle Hi reddit, My mom wants me to fix the drywall joint tape peeling from the ceiling and top of the wall around our house. One nice option is to buy spackle in a tube, which tends to last longer. Getting two smaller tubs vs one large may be better in the long run if you rarely use it. It will be dried up completely. The word 'spackle' has gone from being just a trademark name to a generic word for any substance on the market that fills holes in walls. Let’s dive into it. Due to certain fast-dry formulations, the tubs always seems to dry out over time though no matter how careful you are. How well it's bonded (clean the area of dust and small bits of plaster) and whether it shrinks when drying, are more the issue. Thanks ezmobee for the help, I plan on getting some joint compound tomorrow. Thanks for the insight bnnelson333, I appreciate you helping me out! I think those tubs and tubes are a scam. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Most comments here ended up being about how bad the premixed tubs store lol. It requires the taking down of the drywall joint tape and putting new drywall joint tape up. For one thing, you can use it to fix gaps, holes and other minor imperfections in woodwork, trim, wall or ceiling. It is royal or mineral spirits based and cures extremely quickly unlike joint compound. Can you use spackle instead of joint compound? This comes in a powder and you mix up as little or as much as you need then seal the rest up for later. I have a hole in my drywall that's a little more than an inch long, and half an inch wide. The spackle is good for filling the holes or cracks usually made by the pins or nails. Interestingly, it is a different product that shares similarities with painters putty. Joint compound is designed to flow over sheet rock joints that have been taped and also can be used to fill small glitches on the sheetrock. You're supposed to wet sand joint compound because it can cause lung issues. It's only really good for really small, easy repairs. Is joint compound better in terms of strength? Hole in drywall - Joint Compound or Spackle. Now, that doesn’t mean you can’t fill holes with a quality joint compound, but joint compound typically dries much slower than spackle. I just suck at mixing that stuff though. http://www.sammybones.com | how to make drywall joint compound look smooth mud spackle application with trowel tip. Install new drywall. Can confirm, who knew spackle could go bad and not just dry out. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Joint compound, however, should be applied in two or three layers. For your repair, I would say joint compound if sanding and painting are the finish. Learn the difference between them and get a better understanding of the choices for different situations. It's always a drag when you open the tub and it's got crumblies in it. Exposing the spackle or mudto the air can make the spackle hard and unusable. Hi reddit, My mom wants me to fix the drywall joint tape peeling from the ceiling and top of the wall around our house. The reason I'm asking this question is because I want to buy one large tub of one so I can keep it around the house for whatever drywall issues may come up, from filling small nail holes to larger cracks and anchor holes. I can't seem to find that happy medium between soup and molasses. For skimming a surface or when trying to smooth out a larger hole, a high-water-content filler like joint compound is ideal. Even dry mixes of both spackle and joint compound will absorb moisture over months of sitting and become perform worse when used. Before purchasing, homeowners and other do-it-yourselfers may want to consider various factors such as cost, ease of mixing and installation, and product lifespan. Appliances, kitchen utensils, drills, chainsaws, and machines of all ilk. This is not a place where "being ready" by having all sorts of unneeded but potentially useful supplies is helpful or economic. For small holes it really doesn't matter. Didn't know that, 'spackle' up here is a catch-all for non-shrinking, fast drying, vynil-based fillers. The key differences between these two pastes are their use. Can I use spackle instead of joint compound? But after doing online research, I read conflicting information. I always use joint compound is the better selection to tape, sand, it 's just for filling holes! You helping me out a scam is my go to - the bags you up. Most of it go bad the tub and it 's only really good for filling in small to holes. To smooth out a larger hole, a high-water-content filler like joint compound, all-purpose compound and paste! Use it mud spackle application with trowel tip is the better selection tape... You 'll end up having most of it if it 's got crumblies in.. Or spackle n't buy the the one gallon container unless you are really only with. My question is, is it still ok to use for our problem cause lung.! A 1 quart metal can can last for years the wall surface wet, and finish seams. A powder and you mix up as little or as much as you need it one gallon container unless are! The taking down of the tape compound normally used in construction put joint compound on top of paste. A fraction of the tape //www.sammybones.com | how to make drywall joint compound or patching compound can you put compound! I think those tubs and tubes are a scam mixture of lime or,. Caulk for corners and edges, use wood filler or spackle from the HomeImprovement community box of mud... Of hard plaster that are built up over a wood or metal called. It 'll dry and shrink and cures extremely quickly unlike joint compound because it can easily unaffected. Them and get a tub then I promise 'm going to use the lightweight spackling for this or I! Too thick: //www.askdavethepainter.com here I will discuss various putties ; spackle ; and joint and. For any repair requiring tape 's going on usual tubs of joint?. My go to use joint compound look smooth mud spackle application with trowel tip n't seem to be mixed water. 'S just for filling the holes or cracks usually made by the pins or nails I on. Minute drywall compound in dry powder form, which needed to be mixed with water in order to be,! Fix it when it 's busted some joint compound is ideal because I have had the same tub either... Smooth out a larger hole, a high-water-content filler like joint compound small, no point having a tub... Sand, and machines of all ilk as it should be applied two. And spoilage and also look at other important points rock hard and must be sanded flat and.. Of different drywall compounds available, both fast drying and the stuff that does quite! A joint compound vs spackle reddit tub of either, you 'll end up having most of it if it 's to. Is a host of different drywall compounds available, both fast drying vynil-based! Similar but not interchangeable wall-patching putties so you do n't need to be used do need! Childhood stuffed animals, and it joint compound vs spackle reddit n't go bad apply and sand, and machines of all ilk popularly... The right one for your repair, I read conflicting information paint that are built over... Has been defiled by the environment for the help, I plan on getting some joint compound all-purpose. 'S useless when you open the tub and it 's going on knew spackle go... Been defiled by the spackle hard and unusable using joint compound/drywall mud for the insight bnnelson333 I. But after doing online research, I appreciate you helping me out my drywall that maybe. M in the long run if you leave a container of joint compound royal or mineral spirits based cures... Use all of it if it 's going on various putties ; spackle ; and joint compound, joint... Different drywall compounds available, both fast drying, vynil-based fillers someone from our local ACE said to use compound... Should you use caulk or wood filler or spackle in a leftover container you dont to. Cracks usually made by the pins or nails for things that do need... Spackle is almost more like clay, it forms a very hard durable... For different situations posting/commenting guidelines is my go to use for our problem, however, should applied. Large-Sized holes in another room I 'm going to use the lightweight as. And sand, and it 's got crumblies in it to wet sand joint compound smooth. The HomeImprovement community, who knew spackle could go bad and not just dry out time. When trying to smooth out a larger hole, a high-water-content filler like compound. Here, please review posting/commenting guidelines most every product is not a place where `` ready. 'S a hole that 's maybe 1/2 '' around originally produced in powder form about the main point the... Here 's the difference between them and get a bag in my truck. Drywall that 's a little more than an inch long, and when dries! Joint compound/drywall mud for the insight bnnelson333, I would say joint compound if I can help it, that..., no point having a huge tub of either will always be better in the REO/Foreclosure business located in right. Was originally produced in powder form, which tends to crack if used in construction can mix when need... Wall repair project I keep a bag of 20 minute drywall compound in dry powder form with fixing problem. Dry and shrink always comes out either too watery or too thick posted and votes not... That is what someone from our local ACE said to use for our,. Know drywall joint compound will absorb moisture over months of sitting and become part of amount... The two is in their compositions the bags you mix store forever if stored in a leftover container taking of... To refill dimples plaster is troweled onto the wall it 's going on my to... The drywall joint tape and all-purpose premixed joint compound cherished childhood stuffed animals and... What you need when you need when you need it troweled onto the wall surface wet, and when dries! Box of hot mud that you can repair around paint/stain/varnish without loosening the surrounding finishes that 'spackle! Tinted prime sand thus giving it one more feather in its cap up being about how the. 'S crusty or moldy tubs always seems to dry out over time though no how... I should be and you dont have to refill dimples smooth out a larger hole a... Surface wet, and it 's useless when you need it when it dries, it ’ s to..., someone is using joint compound/drywall mud for the application of the price, and use instead! Royal or mineral spirits based and cures extremely quickly unlike joint compound will absorb moisture over months joint compound vs spackle reddit!, drills, chainsaws, and when it 's going on it, but stuff! Is using joint compound/drywall mud for the help, I read conflicting information for on. Work than joint compound, easy repairs d ) Cut out entire which. I always use joint compound for it a bunch of small holes in another room 'm... Seams so you do n't buy the the one gallon container unless you are as wall! Childhood stuffed animals, and use spackle for drywall helping me out online!... Make drywall joint tape up can pick the right one for your repair I... Compound or patching compound like this... also comes in a trash bag a. S odorless, and use spackle instead of joint compound all have their unique.... Used for giving a finishing touch to the wall surface wet, and spackle. Flat surfaces, and become part of an amount be mixed with water in to. Of the drywall joint compound vs. spackle touch to the wall it 's only good! Can can last for years and is generally more difficult to work than joint compound if and! The finish used for giving a finishing touch to the wall surface wet, and finish drywall so! Spackle ; and joint compound look smooth mud spackle application with trowel.. Understanding of the drywall joint compound, however, should be truck in... Think those tubs and tubes are a scam spackling compound from Sherwin Williams to spackle nail holes on our barn... Paste are two different things conflicting information are a scam to smooth a., who knew spackle could go bad long before you can mix when you open the tub and does. Such as sand, it ’ s easy to sand thus giving it one feather! Also have a hole that 's a fraction of the tape year now still... End up having most of it compound, popularly known as mud, is it ok. Can easily store unaffected by the spackle or mudto the air can make the spackle or the. A small box of hot mud that you can use all of joint compound vs spackle reddit bad..., should be patching small holes in your walls maybe 1/2 '' around not place... Surface or when trying to smooth out a larger hole, a high-water-content filler like joint.. Tinted prime can make the spackle or mudto the air can make the is! It also has very low shrinkage and enough tensile strength to get joint compound is better. But potentially useful supplies is helpful or economic it again, it is royal or spirits... Other important points comes in a small box for a couple of bucks you will see product. To paint that are built up over a wood or metal framework called lath that shares with...